ApApple just built its first touchscreen Mac. Then it gave it the same name as the Macs without one.
Yesterday Apple did something it spent the better part of fifteen years telling us it would never do. It put a touchscreen on a Mac.
It’s the biggest change to the Mac laptop in a generation. And Apple called it… MacBook Pro.
Which would be fine, except Apple is still selling the MacBook Pro. Several of them, in fact. So if you walk into a store this weekend and ask for a MacBook Pro, the only honest answer is: which one?
The event was billed as “Pro and tell.” Apple delivered on the Pro. It forgot the tell.
Count the MacBooks
Here is every laptop on Apple’s website this morning, named the way Apple names them:
- MacBook Neo
- MacBook Air, in two sizes
- MacBook Pro 14-inch, with a choice of three chips
- MacBook Pro 16-inch, with a choice of two chips
- MacBook Pro with PROLED XDR Display, in two sizes, with a choice of two chips
Three names. One of them now covers three different products: a newer chip without a touchscreen, an older chip without a touchscreen, and the touchscreen.
Apple’s way of telling them apart is a suffix: with PROLED XDR Display. That’s not a product name. That’s a spec sheet that wandered into the title. Nobody will ever walk into a store and ask for it. They’ll ask for “the touchscreen one”, which tells you exactly what the name should have been about.
Apple used to be the company that fixed this
When Steve Jobs returned to Apple in 1997, the Mac line-up was a sprawl of Performa models with four-digit numbers that even Apple’s own staff struggled to tell apart. His fix is now business-school folklore. He drew a grid on a whiteboard. Consumer and pro across the top. Desktop and portable down the side. One product per box.
Four products, four names, no overlap
| Consumer | Pro | |
| Desktop | iMac | Power Mac |
| Portable | iBook | PowerBook |
Within two years every box was filled, and every name told you which box you were standing in. You didn’t need a salesperson. You didn’t need a spec sheet. The name was the buying guide.
That discipline became the brand. Apple wasn’t only selling computers; it was selling the relief of not having to think too hard about which one. Every naming decision took a question out of the customer’s head.
Yesterday’s launch puts one back in.
The buying journey, then and now
Under Jobs, the laptop line-up followed the grid. The MacBook was for everyone. The MacBook Pro was for professionals. You knew which one you were before you walked in.
Once you’d chosen, the only real decision was screen size, and that’s a decision anyone can make by looking. The standard model came with everything you needed, including a hard drive big enough for most people. If you were a pro who knew you wanted more storage or memory, you could add it. But that was a customisation for people who knew what they wanted, not a question every buyer had to answer.
Now look at the journey today.
| Step | Then | Now |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | MacBook or MacBook Pro? | Neo, Air, Pro, or Pro with PROLED XDR Display? |
| 2 | Which screen size? | Which screen size? |
| 3 | Done. Upgrades if you want them. | Which chip: M6, M5 Pro or M5 Max? |
| 4 | Which memory and storage? |
Step three is where Apple loses most people. What’s the difference between an M5 and an M6? How is an ordinary buyer supposed to know? Six is a bigger number than five, so the M6 must be better. Except the M5 Max is the more powerful chip. The numbers point one way and the product points the other.
And the word “Pro” doesn’t help either. The MacBook Neo, Apple’s simplest laptop, runs on a chip called the A18 Pro. So “Pro” now appears on the most basic Mac and the most advanced one. When one word sits at both ends of the range, it has stopped meaning anything.
Chips are an engineering story. Apple’s are genuinely world-class, and its engineers should be proud of them. But customers don’t buy chips. They buy what the computer lets them do. The moment the store asks them to decode silicon, the brand has handed its homework to the buyer.
Simplify, clarify, amplify: nought out of three
Credit where it’s due: the MacBook Neo is a clear idea. Bright colours, a simple machine, an obvious buyer in the student. A name, a look and a person, all pointing the same way. That’s how it’s done.
The rest of the range is another story. At Three-Point Branding we judge a brand decision by three questions, and Apple’s laptops fail all three.
Simplify. One name should mean one thing. “MacBook Pro” now means three different products, each with its own set of chip choices. The name no longer narrows the decision. It is the decision, and the customer does the sorting.
Clarify. A good name tells you who it’s for. Who is the MacBook Air for, and who is the cheaper MacBook Pro for? Nothing in either name tells you. And the biggest change Apple has made in years, a screen you can touch, appears nowhere in the name of the product that has it.
Amplify. Apple finally has something to shout about: the first touchscreen Mac, ever. That deserves a name people can repeat at a braai. For months the rumour mill called it the MacBook Ultra. Apple walked away from that, presumably because nobody wanted to be the one who demoted the word “Pro”. Understandable. It’s also how brands get complicated: not through one bad decision, but through a run of reasonable ones nobody wanted to say no to.
The fix fits on a napkin
You don’t need a naming agency for this. You need the nerve to cut, which is the thing Apple used to be famous for.
Four laptops. Four names. Each one tells you who it’s for, and the last one tells you what’s different.
| Name | Who it’s for |
|---|---|
| MacBook Neo | Students. A simple laptop at a student-friendly price, in colours that are half the fun. |
| MacBook | Everyone. The laptop you recommend to your parents, your partner and your accountant. |
| MacBook Pro | Professionals who need serious power. |
| MacBook Pro Touch | Professionals who want the touchscreen and the best display Apple makes. |
The Air folds into the MacBook. The Pro keeps its name, and the new machine gets one word that says everything Apple spent an entire launch explaining: Touch. No suffix, no display jargon. It’s a name anyone can ask for in a store.
Then bring back the old buying journey. Pick your MacBook. Pick your screen size. Done. Each one ships in a standard configuration with everything most people need. If you know you want more storage or memory, add it as an upgrade. The chip name lives on the spec sheet, where the people who care will happily find it. Everyone else gets to buy a laptop without a lesson in silicon.
The point isn’t that Apple needs fewer laptops. It’s that every laptop needs a name that does a job. Right now, one word is doing the work of three, and it no longer tells anyone anything. A name that applies to everything means nothing.
Simple is a choice
None of this takes anything away from the hardware. By every early account, the touchscreen MacBook Pro is a remarkable machine. That’s exactly why the name matters. Great products deserve names that get out of their way.
Apple taught the rest of us that simplicity isn’t the absence of options. It’s the courage to make the hard calls so your customer doesn’t have to. Somewhere in Cupertino, someone had to choose between a clean name and a comfortable one. This week, comfortable won.
Here’s hoping that by next October, Apple remembers how to draw a grid.
0 Comments